Boy, I guess that you ARE in a valley! I often forget how hilly Pittsburgh really is! Your transmitters are close, but are are weak because of the hills. After Feb 17, you are going to have 2 VHF digital stations, so I suggest that you go with an AntennasDirect XG-91 plue a Winegard YA-1713 VHF high-band yagi. As for a preamp: you will need one, but you get rid of the Radio Shack preamplifier, and get a Winegard HDP-269, which has high input capability, and low noise. The Radio Shack preamps are notoriously noisy, which makes digital reception worse. Try a Channel Master 9521 a rotator. When in digital, you should be able to get all of the Pittsburgs stations. I suggest that you mount the XG-91 above the YA-1713 by at least 4' and tilt the front-end of the XG-91 up by 20+ degrees to pick up the defracted signals from the top of the hills nearby.
http://www.wineardhttp://www,channelmaster.comhttp://www.antennasdirect.comhttp://www.pctinternational.com/channel ... lation.pdf