Hello. If you have not checked this reference yet here is a link that can help with making the right antenna/equipment choices :
http://www.tvfool.com/?option=com_wrapp ... c5e6c127f1You will have less difficulty receiving broadcasts from Tucson stations which are line of sight from Florence due to the towers located on Mt. Bigelow, about 8550 ft. above sea level. KGUN transmits on physical channel 9(VHF-HI band). The other channels are in the UHF Range. Tucson stations will probably not require preamplification assuming less than 150 ft. of coax to two receivers.
Phoenix towers are located on South Mountain, somwhat lower elevation than Mt.Bigelow. Reception is still possible. but you will need to have an antenna that is designed to pick up VHF-HI band transmissions since KAET, KSAZ and KPNX all transmit on channels 8 10 and 12 respectively. I recommend you check out the Winegard HD 769* series of VHF/UHF antennas for either application. ( Summit Source or Solid Signal.com are great)
Looking at the TV Fool output for your ZIP (you can input your street address and mast height for more accurate output) the first section of the matrix "Channel" shows the station callsign, physical(broadcast)channel assignment and the Virtual(digital)channel assignment and network affiliation. Next the "Signal" section is divided into NM(Db) which is Noise Margin and Signal Strength(expressed as DBm, or how "loud" the station is at you location) The rest are Distance to transmitter(in air miles), Signal Path(LOS is Line of Sight, 1 edge or 2 edge diffraction and Tropospheric scatter) and Azimuth(compass direction)
As for preamplifiers and antennal rotors, I would recommend order the preamp but do not open it yet. Do the antennal installation and see what you are getting without the signal amp. If you plan to feed multiple TVs and the signal is acceptable at the first tv, you should use a distribution amplifier to feed up to 4 sets or D-VHS or DVR OTA recorders, whatever combination of equipment you may have. As for the rotor, if you want to receive both Phoenix and Tucson stations it will be needed, but be sure your TV Tuners have a feature that lets you add channels from a new scan without erasing the current channel list. Using a rotor usually means having only one TV and one recording device however, so you will need to consider the pros and cons.