A little update...
I got a hold of a like-new antenna, I think is a VHF. Its about 5-6 feet long, and about 4-5 feet wide. I'm also using some no-no RG6, about 25-40ft. I have a cheap indoor booster, which doesn't seem to make any difference at all.
After twirling it around for about an hour, we managed to pick up:
WBBJ ABC (60-70%)
WHDF CW (70-80%)
WSMV NBC (55-65%)
WKRN ABC (55-65%)
Signal Percentages are approx - i'm not in front of the TV, but pretty close from what I remember
And about 7 other channels.
We couldn't pick up either FOX or CBS, which are between 80-86 miles away, and I think are UHF. So would I be correct in thinking I need to order a UHF antenna? If so, whats the very best UHF antenna, possibly directional that can pull in FOX and CBS? Do boosters only help solidify an existing signal, for bad weather and such, or should I get one to help raise my signal enough to pull in those distant stations?
I'm very surprized I can pull WKRN which is about 70 miles away, with this antenna, and crummy cable. Seems like with a good UHF and booster I could pull in FOX or CBS.
I'm located on a hill, with hardly any trees. They just put in a AT&T tower about 100 yards away, so I assume this is a decent location.
It is cloudy right now, so I don't know how that will effect signal once it clears up.

The wife has clear me to spend about $150-200 on additional equipment, if I could get her the super bowl.

Thanks very much for the help!