Here's how I would handle it: You can use a UHF only antenna for all of your other stations: they all lie in the same direction, 220 degrees from your location, at a distance of about 37 miles, WHBF operates on channel 4, a VHF low-band station, in a silghtly different direction, at about 250 degrees and a distance of 32 miles. I would use a
Winegard YA-6260 6 element VHF-low-band yagi aimed at WHBF, and a UHF yagi, like a Winegard HD-9032 aimed that the other stations at 220 degrees. Separate the two antennas by 4' on the same mast , and use a Pico-Macom UVSJ antenna joiner to combine the signals from the two antennas into one new coaxial cable feed into your house. If you are running more that one TV set from your antenna, consider using a splitter-amplifier like the Channel Master CM341x series of amplifiers to recover signal strength lost by cable runs and splitting the signal.
http://www.winegard.comhttp://www.pico-macom.comhttp://manuals.solidsignal.com/AntInstallGuide.pdfhttp://www.solidsignal.com